Dredd vs. Dredd: Who got it right?

So last night I finally saw the new Judge Dredd film starring Karl Urban as the titular “Punisher w/a badge” we all love. My personal choice for Dredd would be Ray Stevenson, the man who IMO nailed Frank Castle in 2008’s Punisher: War Zone. Anyway, as one of the few fans who liked the 1995 Stallone version of Dredd, I thought I’d post my two bits about the new film and who I think did a better job portraying Mega-City One.

*** Major spoilers for those who haven’t seen one of the films discussed ***

You’ve been warned, but keep reading if you’ve seen ’em both or just don’t care about spoilers.

Continue reading